The Institute for Ethics and Economic Policy (IEEP)

 

Fordham is a renowned Jesuit institution with over 165-year history of emphasis on ethics.

 

To promote Governance with Respect Ethics Accountability and Transparency (GREAT)

 

UKRAINE

 

Join a Discussion site, where you can click on “New Topic” or try this link

 

Transparency International’s corruption rank for this country in 2000=87, corruption perception index =1.5

 

: TWO MORE UKRAINE OFFICIALS RESIGN IN GROWING CORRUPTION SCANDAL. Petro Poroshenko, National Security Council Secretary, and Mykola Tomenko, Deputy Prime Minister, both resigned today, in connection with a government corruption scandal that has led to the largest political crisis in the country since President Viktor Yushchenko swept to power earlier this year. Poroshenko resigned amidst allegations that he used his position to enrich himself – a charge he denies; while Tomenko announced at a press conference that he was resigning in protest at corruption in the government. “I don’t want to carry responsibility for people who have created a system of corruption,” he said. The double resignations are another blow for the president, who lost his chief of staff, and political ally, Olexander Zinchenko, five days ago, after he too resigned in protest at high-level corruption. Yushchenko was due to hold a press conference later that day, in which he was expected to announce major changes in the government (Yahoo! News, September 8, 2005, summary by Cecily Layzell).

 

Premier Victor in Ukraine Vote; Abuses Are Seen. Ukraine approached a political stalemate as vote counts of the presidential runoff election indicated that Prime Minister Viktor F. Yanukovich had won, but international observers alleged systemic voting abuses and the opposition candidate refused to accept defeat. With more than 99 percent of ballots counted, the government tally gave Mr. Yanukovich 49.42 percent of the vote to 46.7 percent for Viktor A. Yushchenko, whose supporters turned out in the tens of thousands in Independence Square, vowing not to move until results were reversed. (The New York Times, November 23, 2004 summary by Sherldine Tomlinson).

POLITICIAN CHARGED WITH EXTORTION Olexander Stuparik, former deputy governor of the Khmelnitsky region in Western Ukraine was arrested on April 7 with two suspected accomplices for extorting $73,000 from a local cannery between 1999 – 2003, source from state prosecutor's office. According to a TI' report,  Ukraine was rated last year as one of the top 10 most corrupt countries in the world. (Agence France Presse 13 Apr 2003, summary by Hanh Vu) 

 

Ukrainian justice body asks parliament to sack rebel judge. The Supreme Council of Justice has filed a request with the Supreme Council to dismiss the judge of the Kiev court of appeals, Yuriy Vasylenko who launched two criminal cases against Ukrainian President Leonid Kuchma on charges of murder and corruption. All council members supported Vasylenko’s dismissal on the grounds that he broke the oath and had no right to institute criminal proceedings against the Ukrainian president who has absolute immunity and who can only be brought to justice based on impeachment proceedings. (Financial Times, (February 6, 2003 summary by Sherldine Tomlinson).

 

Kiev, HEAD OF UKRAINE'S ANTICORRUPTION BODY RESIGNS. President of Ukraine, Leonid Kuchma, has issued a decree releasing MP Mykhaylo Potebenko from the post of chairman of the Coordinating Committee for Combating Corruption and Organized Crime. According to MP Mykhaylo Potebenko, there was no need for an anti-corruption committee since "there are many other committees which duplicate one another." (BBC Monitoring Service, December 4, 2002, summary by Pavlidis George).

 

COURT DROPS CORRUPTION CASE AGAINST UKRAINIAN OPPOSITION LEADER A Ukrainian court has struck down corruption charges against opposition leader and former Deputy Prime Minister Julia Tymoshenko and her husband. The decision ended more than a year of probes and high-profile disputes between prosecutors and Tymoshenko. A Kiev court ruled April 30 that the criminal cases against Tymoshenko and her husband Oleksandr were groundless. Tymoshenko had been charged with allegedly trying to illegally transport US$ 100,000 in hand luggage in Moscow’s Vnukovo airport in 1995, large-scale natural gas smuggling in 2001, and paying bribes to ex-Prime Minister Pavlo Lazarenko, who is presehtly in a San Francisco jail on U.S. money laundering charges. Her husband had been charged with misappropriating state funds in metal-trading deals. Tymoshenko have denied any wrongdoing and claimed her political opponents orchestrated the charges against her and her husband. (Yahoo News (Associated Press), May 9, 2002, summary by Sherldine Tomlinson).

 

A NATIONWIDE ANTI-CORRUPTION FORUM SET UP  Several non-governmental organizations and government officials have come together to set up an anti- corruption forum today. According to one of the initiators, the chief of State Tax Administration, Mykola Azarov, the forum would set up a code of good practice for bureaucrats, help expose corruption in government offices and assist in building better contacts with Western organizations.   (BBC Monitoring Service, December 10, 2001, summary by Aruna Balakrishnan).

ALLEGED AVAILABILITY OF EXPLICIT PROOF OF PRESIDENTIAL CORRUPTION AND MONEY LAUNDERING IN UKRAINE WITHHELD BY FORMER GUARD. A former Ukrainian Presidential guard, Mykola Melnychenko, under asylum in the US since last April has claimed that he has several hundreds of hours of recordings of Ukrainian President Leonid Kuchma´s alleged involvement in corruption, international arms smuggling, and deliberate attempts by him to manipulate US money- laundering investigations. US Justice Department has been mounting pressure on Melnychenko to turn over all his recordings, to which he has protested on the grounds of preserving Ukrainian national security interests. Some of the recordings posted on the internet last year by an opposition leader in Ukraine, included President Kuchma’s involvement in the murder of a journalist and other crimes, which had sparked off mass public protests calling for the President’s resignation. Ukraine, which was included in the list of  “non co-operative” countries by the Financial Action Task Force (FATF), a group formed by the G7 to fight money- laundering, has been under tremendous pressure to help track criminal funds. The interest of the US in issuing the subpoena on Melnychenko, is speculated to be related to acquiring a vast source of information on international crime. Alternately, on the attempt by lawyers of former Ukrainian president, Pavlo Lazarenko who is imprisoned in California on charges of laundering upto $114mn through US banks and investments, to make Lazarenko’s charges seem innocuous. President Kuchma has said that though some of the recordings are genuine, others are not, and has alleged that they are a part of a larger conspiracy. Anatoly Kinakh, Prime Minister of Ukraine, has assured US Vice President, Dick Cheney of bilateral support to control money- laundering.(The Financial Times, November 3, 2001, summary by Aruna Balakrishnan). 

 

JOURNALIST DIES OF INJURIES, LINKED TO HIS EXPOSURE OF CASES OF CORRUPTION    Ihor Oleksandrov, a journalist involved in exposing cases of local corruption and organized crime, was attacked with baseball bats in the building of his TV station, TOR, and died days later from his injuries.  Reporters Without Frontiers, the human rights group, has condemned the attack and demanded a thorough criminal investigation.  The lack of a free press in post-Soviet era Ukraine and the unpunished attacks against journalists demonstrates that authorities do not take the matter seriously.    (BBC News, July 7, 2001. Summary by Marg Reynolds)

 

DOZENS OF UKRAINIAN POLICE OFFICERS SENTENCED FOR CORRUPTION. Mykola Anufryev, Deputy Interior Minister, stated the badly underpaid police force is notorious for corruption and practices range from extorting bribes to ignoring criminal activity.  A total of 55 policemen have been sentenced and 127 face legal proceedings for corruption; also, 14 ministry administrators have been dismissed and 57 have been disciplined.  In the first four months of 2001, 10 officers were killed and 138 wounded while on duty.    (KPNews, May 8, 2001, summary by Marg Reynolds).

 

Kiev, HEADLESS BODY THAT OF MISSING JOURNALIST.  According to a team of U.S. experts, the headless body that was found near Kiev is that of a disappeared journalist, Georgi Gongadze. Mr. Gongadze was an honest critic of alleged high-level corruption who edited an Internet newsletter. The experts could not determine the cause of death because the head has not been found and because a lot of time has elapsed. Mykola Harnyk, first deputy state prosecutor, said that the death occurred two to three months before the body was found in November. We remind to you that opposition movements have accused President Leonid Kuchma of involvement in this killing. (Source: International Herald Tribune, May 9, 2001, summary by Pavlidis George). 

 

 EX PRIME MINISTER VOWS TO RETURN.   An opportunity for the Ukrainian people exists in the form of the parliamentary elections to be held next year, in which Viktor Yushchenko, ex-Prime Minister, has vowed to return.  Yushchenko was ousted by a parliamentary no-confidence vote and the reasons for his fall are listed as a commitment to the reforms leading to a market economy and the enormous corruption battle with the energy sector.  The resistance to privatization of inefficient state enterprises, lack of transparency and legality, and the Ukraine’s integration into democratic Europe under President Kuchma has been questioned.    (NZZ Online, May 1, 2001, summary by Marg Reynolds).

 

KIEV.  U.S. Team Confirms Identity of Ukrainian.  The findings of a team of U. S. experts confirmed the conclusion by Russian experts that the headless body is that of Georgi Gongadze.  Mr. Gongadze, an outspoken critic of alleged high-level corruption who edited an Internet newsletter, disappeared in mid-September.  Opposition movements soon accused President Leonid Kuchma of involvement in his slaying.(IHT, May 9, 2001, summary by B. Gray).

 

ASYLUM GRANTED TO BODYGUARD WHO RECORDED UKRAINIAN PRESIDENT    The United States has granted political asylum to Maj. Mykola Melnichenko, former officer in the bodyguard service of Leonid Kuchma, President.  Maj. Melnichenko produced recordings and accused the President of involvement in the death of a journalist, Heorhiy Gongaze.  The tapes contain state secrets, which may cause tremendous damage to the Ukraine.  Although the U.S. State Department said the decision to give Melnichenko asylum was not politically motivated, authorities may question him on various corruption scandals and security matters.    (Houston Chronicle (AP), Apr 14, 2001, summary by Marg Reynolds).

 

DEFIANT PRESIDENT SAYS HE WON’T CAPITULATE TO DEMANDS FOR RESIGNATION DUE TO CORRUPTION   Leonid Kuchma, President, has stated he would not capitulate and called the opposition parties and human rights groups’ demands that he resign, ‘Absurd’.  In the biggest scandal of the ex-Soviet state’s decade of independence, tapes have been published in which a voice like Kuchma’s discusses kidnapping a critical report, Georgiy Gongadze.  Gongadze’s headless and mutilated body was found outside Kiev last November.  In another case, Hanne Severinsen, parliamentary envoy of the Council of Europe, a democracy and human rights monitoring institution, expressed concern about the treatment of Yulia Tymoshenko, one of Kuchma’s prominent opponents, who faces trial on corruption charges and has been held in solitary confinement without adequate medical treatment.    (Yahoo News, Apr 3, 2001, summary by Marg Reynolds).

 

Kiev, COURT FREES KUCHMA FOE. In a blow to President Leonid Kuchma of Ukraine, a Kiev District Court ordered the release of a former deputy prime minister and opposition leader, Yulia Tymoshenko. Mrs. Tymoshenko was arrested in February on extensive corruption charges.  Mrs. Tymoshenko's attorneys argued that prosecutors erred in ordering her arrested. "Tymoshenko is an outstanding political figure in Ukraine," said her lawyer and party colleague, Oleksandr Turchynov. "The only charges against her are political ones," he added (Source: International Herald Tribune, March 28, 2001, summary by Pavlidis George).

 

SECRET RECORDINGS MADE FROM UNDER A COUCH SEEK TO STOP CORRUPTION    Mikola Melnichenko, security officer, has recently transcribed hundreds of hours of tapes tracing virtually all high-level corruption, repression, and some acts of violence to President Leonid Kuchma and his circle of oligarchs, businessmen, and bankers.  Mikola stated that more than $1 billion has been pocketed by the President for personal or political use, that it has been laundered by those in his circle, and that the promised market economy and democracy has fallen under the sway of the powerful and wealthy at the expense of national prosperity.  Prosecutors, tax officials, intelligence chiefs, military, and other security officers have contributed to the atmosphere of cynicism and treachery in the inner circle of Mr. Kuchma’s private little racket.    (NYT,  Feb. 26, 2001, summary by Marg Reynolds).

 

OPPOSITION LEADER WANTS PRESIDENT OUT    Opposition leaders have called upon the international community to push President Leonid Kuchma into resigning and has rallied around their imprisoned leader, Julia Tymoshenko, former deputy premier, who was arrested on charges of large scale corruption and bribery.  Julia claims political foes and corruption officials and businessmen orchestrated the charges.  Investigators have questioned possible involvement of President Kuchma in the murder of disappeared journalist, Heorhiy Gongadze.    (Yahoo News, AP, Feb. 23, 2001, summary by Marg Reynolds).

 

Ukraine’s Mikola Melnichenko, a 34 year old has hundreds of hours of tapes showing that the president Leonid D. Kuchma pocketed $1 billion and ordered kidnapping of a journalist Georgy Gongadze, who was found dead. Igor Bakai, former head of Ukraine’s energy monopoly was also helped in stealing $30 million. (NYT February 26, 2001).

 

FORMER UKRAINIAN LEADER ARRESTED ON CORRUPTION CHARGES. Yulia Timoshenko is a former deputy prime minister of Ukraine. On Tuesday, Ms Timoshenko was arrested on corruption charges after a criminal investigation that led to her removal from the government by president Leonid Kuchma on 19 January. Ukraine's tax administration said Ms Timoshenko had illegally transferred more than $1bn out of Ukraine between 1996-97. Ms Timoshenko is an opponent of Mr Kuchma who is currently facing growing public unrest over his alleged involvement in a murder scandal. Ms Timoshenko, who has been widely praised by the IMF and the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development for reforming the energy sector, has denied the accusations; she insists that she had been framed by Mr Kuchma's close circle. (Source: Financial Times, February 13, 2001, summary by Pavlidis George).

 

Kiev, ANTI-KUCHMA MARCH REACHES KIEV.  An estimated 10,000 protesters from across Ukraine converged on Kiev yesterday, demanding that President Leonid Kuchma step down over the disappearance and killing of an opposition journalist.  Georgy Gongadze was an Internet journalist who ran a news web site critical of Kuchma that exposed high-level corruption.  Georgy Gongadze went missing last September. The decapitated body that was later found, was believed to be his (the Prosecutor General's Office rejected, though, a DNA test that suggested the body was Gongadze's). There are allegations that President Kuchma helped plot to kidnap and kill the journalist. However, Mr. Kuchma has repeatedly denied his involvement in the disappearance. The European Union expressed yesterday its concern about media freedom in Ukraine and urged for a full and open inquiry into Gongadze's disappearance. (Source: The Moscow Times, February 7, 2001, summary by Pavlidis George).

 

KIEV - The president of Ukraine Leonid Kuschma has said he does not intend to dismiss any of his cabinet officials after a report issued by his national security director alleged government corruption in the energy sector. According to the report, the government had overstated budget revenues from energy by as much as 3.9bn hryvnia ($717m), and was arbitrarily funneling revenues from energy to favored companies. So far, the government has not convincingly refuted the charges. (Financial Times, Summary by Fabian Camacho, November 14,2000).

IMF has accused Mr. Yushchenko who headed the central bank of deception.  It is suspected of double counting currency reserves of $1 billion during 1996 to 1998. (NYT, mar. 16, 2K, p. A3) 15];

KIEV - President Leonid Kuchma of Ukraine has said that the fuel and energy complex is the most politicized and criminalized economic sector in Ukraine, followed by areas such as metallurgy, agriculture, and the social sphere. He also criticized the government for failing to draft legislation concerning the legalization of shadow capital. (RFE/RF Newsline, October 12,2000. Summary by Fabian Camacho).

Ukraine's Top Energy Official Vows To Enforce Cash Payment for Bills. (See item 15, April 28, 2000, WSJ Business and Finance – Europe).

Ukraine's government wants parliament to simplify the country's cumbersome tax system to boost investment, and is sending it a proposed pared-down list of taxes, Deputy Prime Minister Yuriy Yekhanurov said Wednesday. The list proposes 25 taxes to replace the existing 39, and includes a "simplified tax system for small businesses and agriculture," Yekhanurov said after a Cabinet meeting. Yekhanurov declined to provide details about what was on the list. Many foreign businesses have cited the country's complex tax system and corruption as key obstacles to investment. (DOWW, May 17, 2000).

Ukrainian energy sector officials arrested on embezzlement charges (RFE/RL Newsline, 22.8.00, http://www.rferl.org/newsline/search/)

Ukrainian deputy premier sees husband's arrest as 'political revenge' (RFE/RL Newsline, 23.4.00, http://www.rferl.org/newsline/2000/08/230800.html) Headline, 25-AUGUST-2000, Link may not work after a few days.

The Index of Economic Freedom (by Driscoll-Holmes-Kirkpatrick) for 2001 places Ukraine in the  “Mostly Unfree” category with a rank of 135 (Ranks range from 1 for Hong Kong to 155 for North Korea, Wall Street Journal, Nov. 1, 2000). H. D. Vinod’s trimmed correlation analysis indicates that countries free from economic regulation are less corrupt. After allowing for some exceptions by 20% trimming, the correlation is near 0.9.

 

Recent news. Worldwide corruption


Country Index
has links to stories and information about corruption and governance in
alphabetically listed geographical regions and countries.

Quick Links to USA, China, India, Indonesia

Resources which track corruption and provide information on good governance from around the world.

Quotes or One-Liners against corruption.



Corruption Info Exchange

Description of our Project and a Request for Funding.

 

IEEP Home



Fordham Economics Faculty

Fordham University


Design: Theo den Brinker


Copyright: Hrishikesh D. Vinod 2000
All rights reserved.
Comments to:
Vinod@fordham.edu


Last Updated:
8 February 2007