Episode 5 - Natural Asset Companies: Unlocking Capital for Nature
-
00;00;11;06 - 00;00;37;19
Leigh Anne Statuto
Hi there! Welcome back to the People Behind the Impact Podcast, brought to you by Fordham University Gabelli’s School of Business Responsible Business Center. My name is Leigh Anne Statuto, and I'm absolutely delighted to be joined today by Olivia Vitali, the managing director for strategic growth at Intrinsic Exchange Group. Olivia has over a decade of experience across traditional finance and ESG investing, spanning large global banks to boutique asset managers.00;00;37;23 - 00;01;01;13
Leigh Anne Statuto
She began her career at J.P. Morgan Private Bank, advising high network clients, endowments and foundations an appropriate asset allocation and investments. She went on to work in hedge funds. She has a BA in finance and international business from Villanova University, and an MBA and sustainability from Stern School of Business at New York University. And now she leads Strategic growth for Intrinsic Exchange Group.00;01;01;13 - 00;01;03;15
Leigh Anne Statuto
And I am so delighted you're here. So welcome.00;01;03;16 - 00;01;06;00
Olivia Vitali
Thank you for having me. I'm so excited to be here.00;01;06;03 - 00;01;10;28
Leigh Anne Statuto
Yeah! We're–– I'm so excited we were able to do this. We've been–– we've known each other for about three years now.00;01;11;03 - 00;01;11;20
Olivia Vitali
Oh yeah.00;01;11;24 - 00;01;27;19
Leigh Anne Statuto
And so, when we were putting together this podcast, I think the work you're doing is fascinating. And I was like, we need to figure out how to get you on here. So, thank you for being here. [Olivia Vitali: Of course.] So, I give a quick background that really breezes over the highlights of your career. But I'd love if you could just, you know, introduce yourself a bit.00;01;27;21 - 00;01;53;00
Olivia Vitali
Sure. So, I’m Olivia Vitale as Leigh Anne said, I'm managing director of strategic growth at Intrinsic Exchange Group, which I'll get to in a second, but my background is more traditional finance. I grew up at J.P. Morgan and I was working in the private bank, working on asset allocation and general wealth management for high-net-worth clients, and I loved that role because I was really in the middle of news flow.00;01;53;01 - 00;02;17;11
Olivia Vitali
I think I've always been someone that's very interested in what's current and trying to understand how the world works, essentially. So, I thought finance was the best way for me to really be in the middle of it. And so, I had a great role there for three years, and then I transitioned to more of the buy side. So, working, as you said, at a few hedge funds that were trading quant funds, it was quant strategies.00;02;17;12 - 00;02;42;23
Olivia Vitali
So, I was in a business development capacity there and helping launch new strategies, talk to clients, etc. The last fund that I was at, I was three weeks into my new job and they said, hey Olivia, I think we're going to launch a carbon transition fund. And I said, I have no idea what that is. And again, I was in a business development capacity, so dealing more on the client side.00;02;42;29 - 00;03;05;07
Olivia Vitali
And they said to me, we want you to do some research around carbon markets. And this was 2017 maybe. So, it was still early-ish for carbon markets, especially hedge funds getting into the space. And so, I took more of a research type role along with my business development role, and just jumped into it. And I had no idea what I was doing.00;03;05;07 - 00;03;35;12
Olivia Vitali
I was working with one of the partners. Long story short, I helped launch three different carbon transition strategies from this hedge fund and learned about carbon and beyond quite a bit. And that's how I fell into this ‘Natural capital space’ is what we like to call it. And my current role. I randomly met the CEO and founder of Intrinsic Exchange Group, Douglas Eger, through a mutual connection, and it was totally random.00;03;35;12 - 00;03;56;17
Olivia Vitali
And I heard his pitch. He actually came into the hedge fund that I was working at, and he pitched natural asset companies, which we'll talk about. And I had no idea what he said for an hour, and I joke–– [Leigh Anne: *Laughing*] Yeah, exactly. And I joke that, it took me six months of being employed there to really fully wrap my head around this concept.00;03;56;17 - 00;04;17;12
Olivia Vitali
But coming from a more traditional finance background, it was the most potentially transformational solution that I had ever heard of. And even though I didn't fully understand it yet, I knew that I had to do it. And so, I joined Douglas about four years ago. It'll be my four-year anniversary next week. I can't believe time has flown so quickly.00;04;17;16 - 00;04;36;13
Olivia Vitali
I've been there ever since. First focused on a more business development investor relations type role and then merged into what we call strategic growth, which is essentially I wear so many different hats at once, and even recently I haven't even shared this with you. Douglas asked me to take more of a chief of staff role.00;04;36;14 - 00;04;37;09
Leigh Anne Statuto
Oh my gosh, amazing!00;04;37;12 - 00;04;47;09
Olivia Vitali
So, I basically we joke that Douglas does the talking and I do the work. But yes, it's very fun. And of course we'll get into what natural asset companies are.00;04;47;10 - 00;05;12;06
Leigh Anne Statuto
That's amazing. I always love these podcasts because some of the folks we've had on our friends, and it's through these that I actually learn a little bit more about how I got into the space. It's great and it's funny. So, we came to know each other, I think three years ago when the Responsible Business Center was being formed and as we were, you know, doing some soul searching of what our center would do, we did a lot of research, and we had reached out to you on a whim saying, hey, this looks cool.00;05;12;06 - 00;05;13;22
Leigh Anne Statuto
We know nothing about it.00;05;13;25 - 00;05;21;08
Olivia Vitali
It was a totally cold email, which I love and is a good little plug for cold emails because sometimes they really work. And now we've had this amazing relationship for three years.00;05;21;09 - 00;05;37;26
Leigh Anne Statuto
Exactly. Yeah. And I remember being like, this is really cool. I don't fully understand. She told us for an hour, but now three years, and I think I'm starting to understand it a little bit more. So, let's get right into it. Can you share a little bit? We'll go deep in the weeds on different parts of it. What exactly does Intrinsic Exchange Group do?00;05;37;28 - 00;05;42;03
Leigh Anne Statuto
What are your mission vision values. Just overarching. And then we'll get deep in the weeds.00;05;42;05 - 00;06;13;08
Olivia Vitali
Yeah overarching. So, we are a startup. We're about 12 people right now. And our technical mission statement talks a lot about finding solutions for funding the nature finance gap with capital market solutions. So, and again, we'll talk about natural capital and what that means. But generally, we know that we need to protect, restore and maintain nature because we know that nature does a lot of work for us as humans.00;06;13;08 - 00;06;41;26
Olivia Vitali
There's a statistic that I'm sure a lot of people have heard that over half of global GDP is highly dependent on nature and the services that it provides, but we have experienced or we have created as humans a market failure in which the benefits of nature are not valued. And so, when we go look at a forest, for example, we only see the value of that forest in the extractive.00;06;41;29 - 00;07;07;01
Olivia Vitali
How much timber can that forest provide for us? But in fact, we know that that forest does a million things for us. It sequesters carbon, it filters water. There's so many what are called ecosystem services that that forest does every day, and in some instances that value that the forest standing is actually more valuable than the timber. But because of that market failure, we don't quite think about things like that.00;07;07;01 - 00;07;28;14
Olivia Vitali
And that's why we have ended up in a society where, Douglas has this chart that we talk to often, where you look at a chart from 1970 to today, and global GDP is a straight line up essentially, well, gradual, but it's going up. And if you look at nature degradation, it is the same slope of the line going down.00;07;28;14 - 00;07;46;11
Olivia Vitali
So as GDP has gone up, nature has gone down. That is not sustainable. We think that nature is an unlimited resource and it's not. So, we need to do a better job of protecting it and restoring it to make sure that we can still live here and that our economy can exist.00;07;46;13 - 00;08;07;00
Leigh Anne Statuto
It sounds not, I don’t want to say simple. It's not simple by any means, but in common sense terms, we need to figure out. And this is something we'll talk about too. How to Live on Earth, which is a documentary I know is featured. But when I started watching the documentary “How to Live on Earth”, they mentioned they're like, if we move somewhere else, we would immediately start thinking, well, what kind of resources do we have?00;08;07;06 - 00;08;22;18
Leigh Anne Statuto
And how do we make sure we're not going over and beyond that? And, you know, over exhausting our resources, which we're very much doing. And I think it's also very much a mentality that people don't even think about it. I mean, if you want to go a little bit more into nature, I think the forest example is great, something everyone can understand.00;08;22;23 - 00;08;30;03
Leigh Anne Statuto
But I guess many folks don't understand ecosystem services or the different pieces. Can you give a few more examples?00;08;30;06 - 00;08;59;04
Olivia Vitali
Yeah, totally. So, I think we can we can continue with the with the forest example. So, as I said, a forest has an ecosystem service called Global Climate regulation. So that forest is sequestering carbon and is also a store of carbon as well. That forest and its ecosystem filters water. It helps soil maintain its fatality. There are pollinators that live in the forest, and they then pollinate plants that we wouldn't be able to do otherwise.00;08;59;04 - 00;09;28;21
Olivia Vitali
So actually, I think pollination is a really interesting favorite example. It's a great example because think about, you know, something that needs pollinators, like almond crops for example. So, we have almonds that grow in California and they are pollinated naturally. Obviously, if we had to recreate the value or the benefit that those pollinators provide to those plants, we would have to incur a cost, right?00;09;28;23 - 00;09;51;20
Olivia Vitali
So, when we think about ecosystem services and what they're economic value is one of the methodologies to determine that value is what's called replacement cost. So, if we had to recreate that pollination process with some manmade thing, or in some cases it's actually humans going out there and shaking, you know, trees together so that the pollen can be spread.00;09;51;22 - 00;10;17;08
Olivia Vitali
That's a labor cost or that's an infrastructure cost, etc. And so, we use that opportunity cost really, in a way, to then figure out what the economic value is of the pollination itself. And again, we take those things for granted. So, in a perfect world, pollination, the service of pollination, the economic value of pollination would be included in the market price of annulment.00;10;17;09 - 00;10;41;21
Olivia Vitali
Now obviously we can't do that, especially in an inflationary environment. Right. But that's why what we're trying to do at IEG is really create a systemic change. We need systemic change so that we are valuing nature in a way that can be incorporated in our economic and financial systems so that we start to make better decisions. And that's really the crux of it.00;10;41;22 - 00;11;12;28
Olivia Vitali
So, in terms of ecosystem services, to answer your question, there's 38 different ecosystem services that can be identified on a particular piece of land. This can be terrestrial landscape. This could be marine landscapes. It can be working landscapes. So, think agricultural landscapes for example. And this is 38 ecosystem services comes from a UN framework. So, countries that at the national level do some type of natural capital accounting.00;11;12;28 - 00;11;50;28
Olivia Vitali
They use this framework. We've taken this framework and adopted it for a corporate purpose. But again 38 ecosystem services. And some of those ecosystem services are what we call nonuse values, which is really interesting in something that was new for me because think about, again, back to the forest example. If you have a home that's next to a park that's filled with a national park forest, for example, that home may have a higher property value right, than a home that is in front of a bill infrastructure like a factory or a AI data center, let's say, to be relevant and timely.00;11;50;29 - 00;11;57;15
Olivia Vitali
And so, we know that that forest is providing value. But again, we're not pricing that value in.00;11;57;15 - 00;11;58;25
Leigh Anne Statuto
And so is that nonuse?00;11;59;01 - 00;12;27;06
Olivia Vitali
That would be nonuse. That would be aesthetic value, right. So even in one of the biggest things that we advocate for is thoughts around indigenous communities, because we know that a lot of the world's nature and biodiversity lives with indigenous communities that have been amazing stewards of their land for centuries, and it's part of their collective cultural ethos to protect and really love nature.00;12;27;07 - 00;12;46;08
Olivia Vitali
Right? And I think as human beings, I could talk about this all day. Human beings, we've lost our spiritual connection to nature. And so, from an indigenous perspective, there's an opportunity to continue that stewardship that they've had, but give them credit for that stewardship. So, we'll get into that a little bit more.00;12;46;09 - 00;13;06;14
Leigh Anne Statuto
This is helpful. I think this sets up because as we always we've done this before in talking about NACs and intrinsic exchange group. There's so many different levels of first what's nature first second what is ecosystem services. So, I think we're at a stage where we can bring in a new topic of NACs, natural asset companies. So, can you start to dissect that?00;13;06;15 - 00;13;07;01
Leigh Anne Statuto
00;13;07;03 - 00;13;33;15
Olivia Vitali
Yes. Let me try to do it succinctly. So, a natural asset company at its core is an operating company that has a specific mandate to protect, maintain and restore the natural assets under its management. Okay. And so, in practice, what that means is that we again, let's go back to the forest. Let's say that there's a forest that is owned by an indigenous community.00;13;33;18 - 00;14;06;16
Olivia Vitali
Again, they've been amazing stewards of it for so long. We have actually have a live example of a project that we're working on with an indigenous community in North America, and they are creating a natural asset company around their forest land. And the idea is they want to retain ownership of the land, and so they will. But the rights to economically benefit from the monetization of the ecosystem services will be licensed to the natural asset company, the operating company.00;14;06;20 - 00;14;32;24
Olivia Vitali
And so similar to if people are probably more familiar with a carbon right or a mineral right. Right. Like, you come in, you're in a developer and you get these rights from the landowner, and then you can monetize those rights. We're essentially doing the same thing. So, the NAC will be able to monetize those ecosystem service rights. But the key difference here is that we IEG are not the developer in creating this natural asset company.00;14;32;26 - 00;15;01;06
Olivia Vitali
In the case of this indigenous community, the indigenous community is putting together this operating company. And so, they will be majority shareholders in a company that owns the rights to the ecosystem services and the benefits that their land provides. And the idea is for this operating company, again, with the mandate to continue to protect, maintain, restore and grow the natural assets and the capacity for it to continue to produce ecosystem services over time.00;15;01;08 - 00;15;44;26
Olivia Vitali
The idea is that operating company, like any traditional company, can raise capital to do that restoration, see that protection out and monetize those ecosystem services. So, are there things like carbon credits that can be sold, biodiversity credits? Is there ecotourism that can be done on the land? Again, the idea is that this indigenous community owns that natural asset company which can raise capital, which especially in indigenous landscape, it's very difficult at times because a lot of these communities are up against extractive industries coming in and saying, hey, we could put, you know, a pipeline through your lands, or we can timber some of your lands and you can make a lot of money from that.00;15;44;29 - 00;16;12;29
Olivia Vitali
These groups need to take care of their people, right? This is a way that resonates with them because it keeps their assets, their natural assets intact. But you can monetize that. And again, the important distinction of a NAC is that its valuation is not only dependent on any cash flows that come into the company, but also the eventual appreciation of what we call ecological performance over time.00;16;13;01 - 00;16;44;12
Olivia Vitali
So as that indigenous community continues to protect, maintain, restore and grow the natural assets under its management, that is reflected in what we call an ecological performance report. So, every year we are identifying those ecosystem services that exist on the land and measuring them. So, looking at biophysical measures and trying to ascertain what is the valuation, what is the economic value that this land is providing.00;16;44;18 - 00;16;48;26
Olivia Vitali
And that is the foundational valuation of the neck.00;16;48;29 - 00;17;05;27
Leigh Anne Statuto
First off, brilliant. And I feel like every time you explain this to me, I feel like I get another part of the equation and I say, oh, I think I get it even more now. The questions that when I'm trying to explain it to someone else and even, I still am asking you are. And they might be the same question, but they might be different, right?00;17;05;28 - 00;17;24;00
Leigh Anne Statuto
Number one is when you say, how do we monetize an ecosystem service? I want you to elaborate on that. And second question, which might go hand in hand is how do you provide a value. Right. I know you're saying you're on the ground. You're doing year over year appreciation, but how do you provide that valuation and how do you monetize?00;17;24;01 - 00;17;26;14
Leigh Anne Statuto
Are they the same question? Are they different questions?00;17;26;16 - 00;17;52;28
Olivia Vitali
Both of them are good questions. And they're kind of one question. So, some of these again 38 ecosystem services that we're looking at that span from very obvious use ecosystem services. So again, think about carbon sequestration or water filtration or pollination as I said. And then there's others that are nonuse like aesthetic or cultural values, things like that.00;17;53;05 - 00;18;22;10
Olivia Vitali
Some of these ecosystem services can be monetized today. Now there's even some new types of markets that a little bit less so in the US, unfortunately, but more in the UK, for example, where there's markets around water or there's markets around nutrients, or there's corporates that would pay a payment for ecosystem service, for conservation outcomes. So, there's a lot of new mechanisms that are popping up around nature outcomes.00;18;22;11 - 00;18;43;06
Olivia Vitali
And so, any of those credits could be under a natural asset company. And that would be how a NAC would monetize some of those ecosystem services. Okay. But to get to the second half of your or your second question, what about those ecosystem services that are not monetized today? So, let's use the example of aesthetic or cultural value.00;18;43;08 - 00;19;11;09
Olivia Vitali
Right. We can think about an economic value of that by doing a survey. So, the marketing industry for example, has done surveys to inform pricing of products for decades. And so, we similarly when I say we I don't mean IEG, I mean a third party that's doing this ecosystem service valuation can go out and do a survey and say, I'm making this up, but how much would you pay to see that this forest is intact in 20 years?00;19;11;15 - 00;19;36;08
Olivia Vitali
So, there's a willingness to pay, and it's not a perfect science, right? Like it's more of an art. And you have to think, I want to I want to explain an analogy that I think is helpful to understand the value of NACs in nature in general. So, think about nature as an asset. Right? Nature is somewhat like gold in that it can appreciate without a cash flow.00;19;36;09 - 00;19;57;29
Olivia Vitali
Now gold is doesn't have a cash flow. I mean, you can trade gold, but we as human beings essentially made up that, hey, we're going to dig into the ground, we're going to take this gold out, and then we're going to put it back in the ground in vaults, and we're just going to pretend that it is the foundation of all value of our money system.00;19;58;01 - 00;20;06;28
Olivia Vitali
And so, nature is like that. And that, in theory at least, nature has more of a fundamental asset value than gold is like, what is gold?00;20;07;01 - 00;20;09;00
Leigh Anne Statuto
You know, of course, what's the what service does that provide?00;20;09;01 - 00;20;37;28
Olivia Vitali
Correct. And so, nature to me is the most fundamental asset that we have. So, think about it. Can appreciate and value the way that gold can appreciate and value. Nature is also a productive asset. Obviously, it creates the opportunity to cut down trees or to do agriculture or sequester carbon, any of these ecosystem services. So, think of nature as like a factory that produces either ecosystem services or food, fiber materials, etc.00;20;38;00 - 00;21;00;29
Olivia Vitali
And then the last thing is think of nature like you would a piece of art. And that's back to that cultural aesthetic value and what every person has a different relationship to nature. So, you may say, I feel really strongly about making sure that forests are still standing in the Amazon. And I feel really strongly about coral reefs in Australia.00;21;01;04 - 00;21;29;05
Olivia Vitali
Right. And the only way to recognize that difference in subjective valuation, like a piece of art, is through an equity instrument that can be traded because you may pay more for that forest to be still standing. And I may pay more for that coral reef to be protected. And that's the fun of the equity market, right? And we think, you know, a lot of people say to me like, oh, well, there's so this is all intangible value and yes and no.00;21;29;08 - 00;21;32;23
Olivia Vitali
My rebuttal to that would be take a look at the equity market today.00;21;32;28 - 00;21;33;25
Leigh Anne Statuto
Right.00;21;33;27 - 00;21;57;29
Olivia Vitali
Right. Like 80 to 90% of the equity valuations today are based on intangible value. And so again to summarize, if we know fundamentally that nature is the most valuable asset we have on the planet. Why can we not create a financial structure around it to value it so that we have an incentive to protect it? And I know this is a long-winded answer, but––00;21;58;01 - 00;21;58;27
Leigh Anne Statuto
That's super helpful.00;21;58;29 - 00;22;22;19
Olivia Vitali
The last thing I want to say on this point is, and sometimes I get looks when I say this, but I think it's very powerful to the right audience, especially to younger generations. I come from a traditional finance background. Finance is completely made up. And I don't say that lightly. Like finance, often people think finance is like biology or chemistry or physics.00;22;22;21 - 00;22;45;17
Olivia Vitali
It's not. Finance is fundamentally in agreement to agree. So, if you have an asset that has value and you have a framework through which that value can be measured and recognized, and you have a willing buyer and a willing seller, the underlying thesis becomes true. That's what finance is. And this concept of oh, we need cash flow to value companies.00;22;45;17 - 00;23;18;22
Olivia Vitali
It's yes, that has been how traditionally it has worked. But again, we made that up. So, what I would offer to people that are wanting to get in this space generally is let's try to think outside the box instead of trying to fit nature into finance. Let's fit finance around nature, because otherwise we're going to end up in the situation that we're in and where we have this huge nature, finance gap, and our earth is degrading.00;23;18;22 - 00;23;29;09
Olivia Vitali
And we know that these ecosystem services aren't going to be infinite. So how do we change that? So that we have a more prosperous future for ourselves and our children, etc.?00;23;29;12 - 00;23;49;26
Leigh Anne Statuto
I love the finance aspect of this, and I look forward to hearing what people say after they hear this. But that's part of what this podcast is. Right. We're at an academic institution to discuss these sorts of challenges and also have these conversations, debates. That's where we really move things forward. Right. And I love the gold example.00;23;49;26 - 00;24;13;19
Leigh Anne Statuto
I think that makes so much sense. And it's not even providing an ecological service. Whereas when you think about nature, it really what I think what the NACs that's really been helpful for me to understand is it was a conversation with you and Douglas when we were at London Climate Week is it's really an exercise in thinking about the fundamental underpinnings of society and how we provide value to so many different things.00;24;13;19 - 00;24;29;06
Leigh Anne Statuto
Art is a great example. I think art really helps to say, well, why is someone paying millions of dollars for this? I personally wouldn't, I can't, but I wouldn't. But it is a really important piece of the puzzle to start understanding. If you're willing to sell a stock, that means someone is willing to buy, and so it's different perspectives on that.00;24;29;07 - 00;24;29;13
Leigh Anne Statuto
00;24;29;14 - 00;24;54;19
Olivia Vitali
Yeah. Or think about the digital asset market cryptographically. I mean I don't want to go too far down that rabbit hole. But regardless about what your opinion is about crypto, the fact is that there's been immense value creation in something or arguably that has no fundamental value. And so again, if we take the most fundamental asset that is known to mankind throughout history, nature, why can't we create a system around that?00;24;54;19 - 00;25;11;16
Olivia Vitali
And I also want to speak to sometimes get the critique of like nature is so fundamental and so important. Like, how can you put a price on nature? Like, are we cheapening nature by putting a price on it, or are we going to exploit nature by putting a price.00;25;11;19 - 00;25;11;28
Leigh Anne Statuto
An ethical question.00;25;12;00 - 00;25;34;23
Olivia Vitali
The ethical question. And it's a good question. And I think what I would say is that we're exploiting nature now. Right? [Leigh Anne Statuto: Right.] Like our financial system, again, we designed it to degrade nature for the benefit of manmade material. And that has been sufficient and has gotten us to this place in society today. And it was probably the path that we had to take.00;25;34;24 - 00;26;03;16
Olivia Vitali
Right. But now we're smarter than that. Especially with AI, there's an opportunity to flip things around a bit. And also like we are entering maybe not with AI now, but like a lower growth period of our economy. And there's potentially a lot of growth from nature as well. And so, to think about how can we again reconstruct our way of thinking and not be so emboldened by this is how we've always done things.00;26;03;16 - 00;26;06;19
Olivia Vitali
So, we can't do it differently. We can because we made it up.00;26;06;20 - 00;26;23;11
Leigh Anne Statuto
Right? Exactly. And I know you're speaking and socializing this concept with so many different players in this space. I'm sure you get a lot of different reactions. What would you say is the overwhelming majority reaction to this kind of idea? Is it acceptance is a confusion.00;26;23;14 - 00;26;25;13
Olivia Vitali
The word–– Yeah, I mean a lot of things, but.00;26;25;14 - 00;26;26;04
Leigh Anne Statuto
I'm sure.00;26;26;07 - 00;26;31;14
Olivia Vitali
The word I would use most often is curious.00;26;31;16 - 00;26;32;11
Leigh Anne Statuto
That’s a good word.00;26;32;29 - 00;26;54;11
Olivia Vitali
Yeah. Curious. And sometimes I find that people are in awe of it. Not because they think it's the best idea in the world, or it's the worst idea in the world, but it's so different, and it really forces people to think outside the box whether they agree with it or not. And I think it starts to get to the crux of the problem of systems thinking, right?00;26;54;12 - 00;27;22;12
Olivia Vitali
Like, we want people to think in a systems mindset. And if we're so siloed in our own industries and our own objectives, like we're missing the bigger picture, or no pun intended or maybe pun intended. We're missing the forest through the trees. Exactly right. And so, there's an opportunity. We are so creative as human beings. And I think about this as it relates to AI as well, because there's so much fear mongering around AI.00;27;22;12 - 00;27;44;06
Olivia Vitali
And I'm more of like a techno optimist myself, right or wrong. But I cannot recreate human creativity. We are creative, a creative species, and we have the ability to create new financial instruments that are going to propel us to a different future than the path that we're on now. So why not do that?00;27;44;11 - 00;28;04;04
Leigh Anne Statuto
We could use that optimism. I appreciate that that wasn't a question, but wow, I needed that. Do you have any examples you can share a little bit? I know you spoke about indigenous populations and how we're engaging and or how they're engaging in this way. How are corporations engaging with NACs? Have you seen any examples? I don't know if you can share anything specific, but overarching.00;28;04;05 - 00;28;36;17
Olivia Vitali
Yeah. Let me let me share some generalized examples of corporates thinking about natural asset companies. So, think about a CPG (Consumer Packaged Good) company. And this is this is actually a live example. I just won't give names. But working with a CPG company, global CPG that you would know the name of that has dairy products right. They have a dairy farm across the UK and they are trying to help some of their farmers transition to regenerative agriculture.00;28;36;20 - 00;29;04;29
Olivia Vitali
And a lot of times the or in this case ranchers, a lot of times the ranchers don't have the technical assistance, don't have the funds to transition to regenerative agriculture. But from a CPG perspective, it's really crucial because they know not only are there consumers demanding more sustainable practices, but at the same time, they know that they need to eventually do this from a resiliency and risk mitigation perspective as well.00;29;05;02 - 00;29;23;06
Olivia Vitali
So right now, if a CPG is wanting to transition their dairy shed to regenerative agriculture, it's a huge expense for the CPG, right? With not a lot of tangible, concrete return on investment immediately. Now maybe again long term you get higher resiliency supply chain.00;29;23;06 - 00;29;24;19
Leigh Anne Statuto
But that's more short term.00;29;24;20 - 00;29;49;23
Olivia Vitali
Yeah, and it's hard to measure today. And so, think about that company that is saying hey I could do a natural asset company around this dairy shed. And I can co-invest in the natural asset company in which my ranchers that I have long term supply relationships with can be owners in the naturalistic company alongside me as the corporate. And that aligns our incentives.00;29;49;24 - 00;30;19;16
Olivia Vitali
And the NAC can then raise external institutional capital to transition those ranches from conventional to regenerative agriculture, providing the technical assistance, providing capital and providing a separate structure separate from the CPG. The way I like to talk about it, if people are familiar with the term insetting, it's an outsourced insetting tool for corporates because again, right now it's just an expense.00;30;19;20 - 00;30;47;17
Olivia Vitali
It could sit on their balance sheet as an asset, and as that natural capital improves, the land is more productive of ecosystem services. That value is captured in the NAC, and that could increase the capital appreciation of the stock over time. And so, it's an opportunity for corporates to get involved around supply chains primarily. The other use case on corporates, which is interesting in Douglas actually in Australia as we speak.00;30;47;18 - 00;31;12;06
Olivia Vitali
[Leigh Anne Statuto: Wow.] Talking to forest product companies. So is there a way to timber more sustainably. We know the answer is yes, but a lot of these companies again are only getting value from the harvest of their timbering. But they're doing timbering in a sustainable manner, and they're not capturing the value of those other ecosystem services that result from that sustainable operation.00;31;12;12 - 00;31;31;15
Olivia Vitali
And so, could a NAC sit on top of a forest products company, or could a forest products company even be transitioned into a NAC? So, there's an opportunity there. But the idea is anywhere where natural capital is being undervalued or underutilized, there's an opportunity for a NAC to come in.00;31;31;22 - 00;31;56;24
Leigh Anne Statuto
This provides such a positive spin on, I think, what is often a really depressing field to be in because it provides those opportunity pieces. And when I speak with students and folks on sustainability, I'm often touting long term value creation or resiliency. And I think this really encapsulates both of those really, really well. Because we're coming up on time, I'm going to start to there's so we could talk about this.00;31;56;26 - 00;31;58;09
Olivia Vitali
I always go way over.00;31;58;12 - 00;32;24;15
Leigh Anne Statuto
There was so many other questions, but maybe for another time. So, the one thing I want to talk about is in collaboration with Intrinsic Exchange Group. Over the past couple of years, we have now formed the Natural Asset Accounting Standards Board or NAASB and NCAP Natural Capital Accounting Principles. We're so excited that this is a responsible business center, in collaboration with so many of the world's leading people in this, including Intrinsic Exchange Group.00;32;24;18 - 00;32;30;15
Leigh Anne Statuto
Can you speak a little bit to these frameworks and what the goal of NAASB and NCAP is?00;32;30;18 - 00;32;54;25
Olivia Vitali
Yeah, great question. And first of all, we're thrilled to be partnering with Fordham. You guys have had a historic run in supporting these types of frameworks. So, we're really excited about that. Generally, one of the biggest barriers to scaling nature finance is inconsistent measurement. And especially when we're talking about valuation, there's really two parts of valuation. It's understanding the biophysical measurements.00;32;54;25 - 00;33;21;01
Olivia Vitali
So, like how much carbon is being stored, how much carbon is being sequestered, etc. And then the valuation aspect, how do we come up with what that price is right for. Or I should say the market value is for that ecosystem service. So, we need a framework that governs that. And we at IEG we have a chief economist Tanya, on staff who is incredible, has her PhD in natural capital accounting and has been doing this for decades.00;33;21;09 - 00;33;46;11
Olivia Vitali
But we couldn't create that standard on her own. So, as I said earlier in the conversation, we have adopted a UN framework to identify those 38 ecosystem services and the valuation methodologies. But what we did is took that framework, made it fit for purpose for a corporation, and then externalized it to Fordham University Responsible Business Center to essentially incubate this framework.00;33;46;16 - 00;34;11;03
Olivia Vitali
And what the framework seeks to do is create a robust, transparent and independent framework for natural capital accounting. So, think of it as comparable to GAAP or IFRS for traditional financial accounting. So, every natural asset company will have its normal financial statements that will govern, or I should say will measure any of the financial revenue that comes in costs, etc.00;34;12;09 - 00;34;40;12
Olivia Vitali
But then there's an ecological performance report. And this is really the quote unquote invention of the NAC is we have this performance report that details and measures the capacity for that land to produce ecosystem services. And that report is based on this framework that we've externalized to Fordham. So, think about it as comparable to GAAP or IFRS, but for natural capital accounting and ecological performance.00;34;40;17 - 00;35;15;08
Olivia Vitali
And the framework itself is very I think this is important principles based rather than prescribing specific biophysical metrics. And I think that's one downfall, unfortunately, of the carbon markets, is there's so many different standards and frameworks and principles, etc. it's very confusing. And what we're trying to do is think about ecosystem services in terms of dollar value. What is the aggregate ecosystem service value that this land is producing on an annual basis, and have that be comparable to what we already know in GAAP or IFRS?00;35;15;10 - 00;35;44;08
Olivia Vitali
And as I said before, importantly, it covers the full spectrum of these ecosystem services, not just those that can be monetized today. So, the partnership with Fordham, we've externalized the framework. We have a governance and reporting committee. And so, the idea is to have this framework continue to evolve and be robust, comprehensive, transparent from an investor perspective. Investors need that to be able to invest in a natural asset company.00;35;44;11 - 00;36;09;23
Olivia Vitali
They need, as Tanya always tells me, decision, useful information. So that is the goal of this framework. And a quick note to say that the framework is obviously being developed for natural asset companies, but it will have applications outside of natural asset companies as well. So back to the corporate example. A corporate could use this framework to identify the ecosystem services that are on lands that it owns for example.00;36;09;25 - 00;36;26;10
Leigh Anne Statuto
Amazing. And we are so excited to be doing this. We've been working on it for quite some time now, and the folks that are on this, NAASB, the board are incredible thought leaders in the space. And Barbara Porco, at a Climate Week event, had said, “accountants will save the world.”00;36;26;13 - 00;36;27;03
Olivia Vitali
Yeah, she has a T-shirt I believe of that00;36;27;03 - 00;36;46;26
Leigh Anne Statuto
Yes, I am not accountant. But I will say in those roundtable discussions, when we were really looking a little bit more into this, it was, how is this audited? What are investors looking for? And it was some really of those decision useful information that we really do need the accounting practice and which is great because I think this brings in the interdisciplinary approach.00;36;47;01 - 00;37;06;10
Leigh Anne Statuto
You need the environmental piece. You need the accounting piece; you need the finance piece. And there are so many different aspects to really make this come to fruition. So, in closing out, I think, I hope I'll say I think and I hope that when folks are listening to this, they're excited and they're saying, what can I do? How do I get involved in this?00;37;06;10 - 00;37;20;29
Leigh Anne Statuto
And I know a lot of this is still in the works. A lot of its institutional investors, I believe. But can you just give a little bit of an overview of what can people do to engage with next? Is there anything at this stage or is it down the road and or what can they just do to promote your work?00;37;21;01 - 00;37;46;07
Olivia Vitali
Yeah, thanks for asking the question. I think there's potentially a lot of things. I think first and foremost, continue from a student perspective to be interested in these sustainability issues and to think outside the box, right. Like so much of sustainability, I think is reporting and disclosure focused. And that can be exhausting in corporate settings because, you know, if you're the CFO, you're like, oh my God, I'm spending so much money on reporting.00;37;46;07 - 00;37;54;24
Olivia Vitali
We had a CFO of a luxury brand in the UK that told us that they were spending 50% of their sustainability budget on reporting.00;37;54;25 - 00;38;01;21
Leigh Anne Statuto
I'm so not surprised. Yeah, it is. And it's so important to do this. [Olivia Vitali: It is.] However, what are we losing in that?00;38;01;23 - 00;38;21;07
Olivia Vitali
Yeah. I mean the disclosure is important and crucial. But once you do the disclosure, like to what end? Like you have to do something on the other side. Totally. And we're so focused on disclosing the liabilities that these companies have and not creating an opportunity for them to have an asset on the other side that can balance that liability.00;38;21;10 - 00;38;54;23
Olivia Vitali
And so, thinking about nature as an asset, generally in school, etc., and NACs specifically we're still at a startup phase, right? Like we are working with different institutional investors and banks etc. to really try to institutionalize this idea. But it's going to take time. [Leigh Anne Statuto: Yeah.] I think from the perspective again, back to students is we're hoping with Fordham that we eventually create some kind of training program around natural asset companies and natural capital accounting and thinking through like, case studies around NACs.00;38;54;23 - 00;38;56;15
Olivia Vitali
I think that's really the biggest thing right now.00;38;56;20 - 00;39;04;15
Leigh Anne Statuto
Our conversation started three years ago on a case study. Yeah. And then occurred in something even larger. But we might need to go back to the case study.00;39;04;17 - 00;39;29;27
Olivia Vitali
And we would love to have conferences and classroom sessions where we're describing what NACs are and the structure itself is meant to be very flexible. And anyone with I mean, the land has to be at a larger scale. You know, we're not talking about a couple hundred acres here like it's, you know, 100,000. Usually just because to get capital markets involved, you need that type of scale.00;39;30;01 - 00;39;34;29
Olivia Vitali
But there's a lot of different use cases for NACs. And the structure itself is quite flexible.00;39;35;00 - 00;39;35;20
Leigh Anne Statuto
00;39;35;22 - 00;39;47;07
Olivia Vitali
And I think finally just being open to how the space is going to evolve. Like I've had a couple student conversations recently and they're like how do I get into this space.00;39;47;09 - 00;39;55;24
Leigh Anne Statuto
Yeah. That was going to be my final question for you. [Olivia Vitali: Sorry.] No no no, that's great because our students are always like, this is good, but what's the future? So, any thoughts on that would be amazing.00;39;55;27 - 00;40;17;22
Olivia Vitali
Yeah, and I don't know if this is a helpful or unhelpful thought, but I say it all the time. I couldn't have guessed that this would be what I am doing today. And I was when I was working at JP Morgan, it was like, and this was 2014, this is when ESG was just starting to become a thing, right?00;40;17;26 - 00;40;46;00
Olivia Vitali
And ESG is kind of faded, at least in this country. But what I want to say is that it's likely, again, especially with AI, that the job you may be doing in five years probably doesn't exist today. So true. And so just be open to experiences and learning as much as you possibly can about the space and not being so focused on, like, I have to go on this specific path because again, the path is going to diverge.00;40;46;00 - 00;41;09;00
Olivia Vitali
And I guess that's a good life lesson in general. It's like you don't know what's going to happen. And so, I always go back to my fundamental value of being curious. I am so curious about a million different things. And that's what led me into finance. As I started the conversation with saying, is, I was just obsessed with like, I need to be in the middle of what's going on.00;41;09;04 - 00;41;24;11
Olivia Vitali
You know, that's why I live in New York City. Sometimes I'm like, why do I live here? Has been so much money on rent, and I have a small apartment, you know, but it's like I live here because I'm in the center of the universe. It feels like. Right. And like, that's what I think is interesting about nature.00;41;24;12 - 00;41;45;28
Olivia Vitali
Finance, too, is because nature is so fundamental. This industry, if you want to call it that, is so new and it's evolving so quickly and could really help change the world. And that to me, I mean, I joke with Douglas, my boss, all the time, I don't like saying this to him, but I'm like, this is actually one of the only jobs I've really, really enjoyed.00;41;45;29 - 00;41;46;28
Leigh Anne Statuto
Yeah.00;41;46;28 - 00;41;57;07
Olivia Vitali
Truthfully, and it's because we're doing something new every day and things are constantly changing and just being open to that change and seeing where it brings you is the best advice that I have.00;41;57;09 - 00;42;13;24
Leigh Anne Statuto
That's so wonderful. And I think, you know, I always bring in the Jesuit perspective, but curiosity is such an important part of this, and I think often, and I was definitely in this stage when I was a student as well. It's, well, what's the next step? What's my five-year plan? And understanding that things open and unfold before you?00;42;13;27 - 00;42;32;09
Leigh Anne Statuto
But having that curiosity and willingness to be creative, right, I think is such a great way to kind of leave off. So, Olivia, this was wonderful. Thank you so much for being here for all of our listeners. If you enjoyed this conversation, we really encourage you to subscribe to the series. We'll have a lot more great conversations in this area.00;42;32;12 - 00;42;48;12
Leigh Anne Statuto
Always welcome a quick review. We'd love to hear what you're thinking and please share it with others. We're really trying to spread the word about the value of NACs, but also the value of nature and the role that we can really all play in understanding how we can move into a better world. So, thanks all for listening. Olivia, thank you so very much.00;42;48;12 - 00;42;49;22
Olivia Vitali
Thank you for having me.00;42;49;24 - 00;42;50;13
Leigh Anne Statuto
Take care.